A few weeks ago my daughter mentioned to me that she didn't really care for Sheryl Crow's last couple of albums. Her favorite is the self-titled Sheryl Crow which reflects the stormy nature of Crow's life after the success of Tuesday Night Music Club. My daughter prefers the angst versus the more mellow tunes Crow has produced as of late. My almost 21 year old deadpanned to me, "I hope she and Lance break up so she can start making some better music."
I don't think she really intended any ill-will towards them. But here we are and they have split. I'm not glad they have split and the pain it brings them (I can't imagine doing a relationship as celebrities), but there is also something about pain that can bring clarity to the human condition and the human soul. Somehow my daughter gets that.
My mood as I write this next part is important. I am not glad for the pain Armstrong and Crow are dealing with at this time. My heart aches for them because I see the pain living together as husband and wife before being husband and wife brings to people in this land. I am not writing from some past or future idealized Utopian relationship realm. The bible is full of sexual sin, the pain it brings, sometimes the redemption of the pain, just about all the way through. God does often put meaning to our pain but he doesn't take away the messiness of being human in community.
As another premarital class approaches I know that I may be the first person many of the couples in the class hear say that living together before marriage isn't a good idea. There is much research that shows in fact that couples who live together are more likely to divorce and have about a 10% chance of being together in ten years. Check out The Marriage Project from Rutgers for great info.
So, living together before marriage actually increases the chance of divorce. I think there are many reasons for this. One is that couples that tend to hook up quickly are emotionally immature and tend to look for a member of the opposite sex to validate who they are and to feel good. These folks can be very passionate and fun but also impulsive. They don't tend to deal with problems in life head on. They may 'know' the person for a week and be 'soul mates' and move in like it will last forever. Their pain and struggle in living is magically gone. After a while everyones annoying traits begin to show up, conflict isn't done well, and it is on to the next relationship.
On these folks behalf, they often grew up in chaotic homes. There is often addiction and/or abandonment and they were never taught to handle conflict well and deal with life head on. It was easier to go get drunk or laid or both or busier at church or busier in ministry or abuse another etc. We are ingenious as humans in our ways to avoid dealing with reality. The bottom line is they learned to not do life head on and aren't doing life head on. They have soul wounds that could use healing before they enter into another serious relationship.
The second reason applies to folks who are a little more emotionally mature but have bought into the belief that a little trial run is practical before marriage. There are various types of intimacy. Sexual tension helps other types of intimacy to grow. In the crucible of sexual tension, spiritual, emotional, and non-sexual touch intimacy have a better chance to flourish. I watched the movie, Serenity yesterday and the day before. Great themes in this movie and in the Firefly series btw. Oh wait, it was in the last episode of Firefly, Jayne (who is a rough guy--kinda like a boy named Sue) asks the Shepard, played by Ron Glass about being celibate. He isn't tactful and mentions masturbating all the time. The Shepard says, "No". Jayne inquires if all his parts are still working and The Shepard indicates they are. He says, "I just channel that energy elsewhere."
I think that is key. If in the early stages before marriage a couple can channel those sexual energies into other areas of intimacy their relationship and marriage will be on a much more solid foundation to handle the ups and downs and struggles and conflicts that come with doing life together. Staying sexually abstinent doesn't solve all your problems before marriage but it generally helps deepen the ties between a couple allowing them to weather the tough times together.
I have no idea the specific reasons Crow and Armstrong are splitting. But I do hurt for him and her and especially for his kids. While it isn't a popular thought to wait until getting married to live together and to have sex (it doesn't solve everything and yes we all know couples who did live together and are still doing well) it generally gives a couple the best odds of having a successful relationship in marriage.